# SURVEY: bit precision vs area, record 7-card images vs the Qwen GPTQ-2 (Q5120) images, and the room left to enlarge the 2-bit GEMM (2026-11-16)

Program: the 7-card **TARGET-side** 4C1 drafter (ATT x4 TP4 + MLPV x2, ONE drafter; Qwen3.8-27B target, drafter = Qwen EAGLE-4 GPTQ v2 2-bit, H 5120). Motto: a research track never ends by denying the idea; a wall is a measured constraint to engineer around, toward the fastest flashable PDI.
Agent: survey census for box1-qwen-junior. User question (verbatim, 2026-11-16): "others did get larger... so I want to see if we can use the extra space to enlrge the gemm for 2 bit... can you do a survay on the current bit preicions - area trade versus the new image".
USER RULING relayed by the coordinator (2026-11-16): **activations are A16 on the Qwen GPTQ-2 images, for accuracy.** Every headroom row in §1 is priced at A16.
Rules kept: read-only on every fork and build; nothing killed; nothing deleted; no build launched; Vivado runs only on my VMs (buildx04 / buildxd00 / buildy00); bulk scratch `/mnt/hdd_data/eagle4_scratch/qwen_gptq2_20261116/survey/`.

**Layout: §0 answers; §1 holds every calculation, projection and hypothesis; §2 to §6 hold only measured values with their sources.**

## 0. Answers

1. **Binding resource per card (measured, placed).**
   - **Record ATT 0x13BE:** SLICE in SLR0, at 98.12 %. SLR0 also carries DSP at 89.0 %.
   - **Record MLPV 0x1361 (M1361 final):** SLICE in SLR2 (94.55 %) and SLR1 (93.44 %). Next come SLR1 DSP at 84.5 % and SLL SLR1<->SLR0 at 78.2 %.
   - **Q5120 ATT 0x1346 / 0x134A:** SLICE in SLR1, at 93.3 %. SLR0 is almost empty: SLICE 10 %, LUT 3.8 %, URAM 0, DSP 0.5 %. The device as a whole is at SLICE 55 %, LUT 26 %.
   - **Q5120 MLPV 0x1349:** SLICE everywhere: device 94.45 %, SLR 92.8 / 93.4 / 97.2 %.
   - **0x135E:** close to the same netlist as 0x1349 (synth u_array 312,320 vs 311,050 LUT), placed with AggressiveExplore. It measures SLICE 78.8 % device / 90.8 % SLR1. So **SLICE is partly a placement outcome; LUT is 53 % on both**.
2. **Where the bits went (§3 to §4).**
   - **The 2-bit weights stayed in URAM** at 16 codes per 32-bit word on every image.
   - **The MLPV GEMV changed precision class.** The record MLPV computes 2-bit x **A16 on DSP58**: E3 packed dot, 2 products per DSP58, 5,120 DSP for 256 lanes. The Q5120 MLPV computes 2-bit x **A8 in LUTs**: LUT-GEMM lane with a per-column zero bank, 311K LUT and 1,889 DSP for 256 lanes.
   - **The MLPV URAM grew 512 -> 1,280** because the Q5120 v0 split put G7 on the MLPV, with 2.6x larger weights.
   - **G8 went from fp16 rows (788 MB head) to 2-bit rows (340 MB).** The synth u_g8 still grew 314K -> 358K LUT, because H 5120 and 248K vocab offset the measured -29K LUT of the 2-bit dot.
   - **The fp16 seams grew 2-4x** (H 3072 -> 5120 plus the G7 hand-off).
3. **Headroom to enlarge the 2-bit GEMM at A16 (§1.3):**
   - **ATT card:** SLR0 is the space, with about 85K SLICE, 3,965 DSP and 677 URAM free after the base. At A16, neither lane form alone reaches the v0 L512: the LUT lane gives 480 lanes (340 at the 2.1x price) and the DSP58 E3 lane gives 401. A **per-die hybrid gives 631 lanes (556 at 2.1x): FITS**. The largest products per cycle is LUT K64/K128 at x1.49: 22K to 29K.
   - **MLPV card:** at A16, **only the DSP58 E3 lane fits L256** (382 lanes max). The LUT lane at A16 reaches only 215 (151 at 2.1x). The largest products per cycle is E3 K64, 15,040, DSP-bound.
   - **SLL is not the wall for the array on either card** (ATT 17.6 / 11.8 % used; MLPV 65.8 % used, about 6.4K free per cut).
4. **The URAM read width is the free K lever.**
   - **What a URAM gives:** a URAM288 is 4,096 x 72 with 2 ports, 144 b per cycle. The shipped bank packs two 32-bit (16-code) words per 72-bit row and reads 32 codes per lane-cycle, about 44 % of what the URAM offers.
   - **K64:** a 64-bit entry at half the depth needs no extra URAM. It is DSP-free on the LUT lane; on the DSP lane it costs +16 DSP per lane.
   - **K128:** needs the lane's 2 URAMs read side by side. Both v0 cards have 2 per lane.
   - **URAM per card is set by the weight bits, not by K:** about 730 minimum for the ATT and about 442 for the MLPV.
5. **Instrument limit:** the SMBus licence served to the VMs (2101) currently returns `FlexNet -95,378 Connection reset by peer` (`[Netlist 29-57]` on `axi_smbus_rpu`), so **no routed full-chip dcp could be opened today.** Two consequences:
   - **Per-SLR numbers** come from each build's own placed report (and from the M1361 routed `-slr` report).
   - **Per-instance numbers** come from `report_utilization -hierarchical` on each build's **drafter IP OOC synth dcp**. That dcp holds only our RTL and needs no licence. Its counts are **pre-opt**: they include logic that opt_design later prunes, such as the legacy fp16 dot in the Q5120 u_g8.
   - **No per-instance per-SLR split was measured.**

---

## 1. Calculations and hypothesis (every derived number in this document)

### 1.1 Per-SLR capacity used below [D on the place reports]
The capacity of each SLR is computed as used / % from `Q46_place_report_utilization_0.rpt:393-412`, cross-checked against the used + free sums in `SYNTH_CENSUS_WEEK_20261105_12.md:490-510`.

| SLR | SLICE | LUT | DSP58 | URAM | BRAM tiles |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| SLR0 | 112,527 | 900,528 | 3,984 | 677 | 1,341 |
| SLR1 | 102,530 | 820,161 | 3,456 | 624 | 1,200 |
| SLR2 | 106,719 | 853,519 | 3,408 | 624 | 1,200 |

### 1.2 Per-lane prices (inputs are the measured rows of §5; the scaling is mine)

**A8 LUT lane, in the image: 277 SLICE, 1,082 LUT, 6.0 DSP, 1.5 BRAM tiles, 2 URAM per lane.**
- Source: the placed 0x1346 SLR2, which holds exactly the 256-lane array: all 512 array URAM, 256 RAMB36 of scales and 256 RAMB18 of zeros sit there. That die measures SLICE 70,856, LUT 276,918, DSP 1,540, BRAM 384, each divided by 256.
- The record ATT lane is cheaper. 0x13BE SLR2 holds 341 lanes in 82,885 SLICE, so at most 243 SLICE per lane. The LUT rows below are therefore slightly pessimistic.

**A16 LUT lane = the A8 price x 1.49, or x 2.1.**
- x 1.49 is the measured ratio of the narrow-tree (H2) lane: 1,673 vs 1,122 LUT (`LUTGEMM_LANE_E1_20261102.md:26-27`). The shipped lanes are narrow-tree (CSA_NARROW 1, `verilog/clean7c/docs/ARRAY.md:225`).
- x 2.1 is the coordinator's figure. It equals the A16 *multiply* lane against the A8 LUT lane (2,701 / 1,261, `DESIGN_FABLE_FULL2BIT_LUT_ARRAY_20261102.md:31`), so read it as the conservative bound.
- At A16 the A8Q quantizer goes away: -5.3K LUT, -96 DSP (§5.1). This is not credited below.
- **ADDENDUM 2026-11-16 (later the same day): use the x 2.1 column as the central estimate.** The Fable GEMM agent routed the same 8-lane datapath harness at AW=16 (buildxd00; `DESIGN_FABLE_GPTQ2_GEMM_20261116.md` §1.8, commit `8d6a51568`). It measures 1,339 LUT / 642 FF / 206 SLICE per lane at K32, against 667 / 443 / 110 at A8 (§2.3 of that doc). That is 2.0x LUT and 1.87x SLICE, much closer to x 2.1 than to x 1.49. The 1.49 ratio is a synth-only number from the full lane (`LUTGEMM_LANE_E1:26-27`).
  - Same run: A16 K64 = 2,541 LUT / 388 SLICE per lane, and A16 W=2 = 2,671 LUT / 406 SLICE per lane.
  - At A16 a DSP58 carries 2 products, not the 3 to 4 of the A8 packing, so the E3 rows above (2 per DSP58) are the right DSP-form price.
  - What this changes: **ATT L512 at A16 fits only as the hybrid (556 lanes at x 2.1).** The MLPV conclusion is unchanged: the E3 DSP lane fits L256, and the LUT lane does not.

**DSP58 E3 lane at A16, 2 products per DSP58: about 206 SLICE, 20 DSP58, 1.6 BRAM tiles, 2 URAM per lane.**
- Source: the record 0x1361 synth hier gives 575 LUT, 539 FF and 20 DSP58 per lane. The 20 DSP58 are 17 in the packed pair dot, 1 in the lane, 1 in the bank and 1 in the scale (§5.3).
- To that I add +45 LUT and one RAMB18 per lane for the per-column zero, which the record lane lacks (`LUTGEMM_LANE_E1:19`).
- SLICE is estimated as the larger of LUT / 3.91 and FF / 2.61, using the packing of the 0x1346 array die: about 206 per lane.

**K scaling.**
- LUT lane: +105 SLICE per lane per doubling of codes per lane-cycle at A8 (Fable harness K64, `DESIGN_FABLE_GPTQ2_GEMM_20261116.md` §2.3), x 1.49 at A16.
- E3 lane: +16 DSP58 per doubling (32 more products at 2 per DSP58), and +25 % SLICE (a guess).

**Non-array bases.**
- **ATT** = 0x1346 SLR0 + SLR1, plus +16K SLICE on SLR0 for G7 on the ATT and u_tp at L512. That delta comes from synth: 0x13BE u_tp 104,881 vs 0x1346 50,679, plus SiLU 3,010 and the r4 seams 7,565, about +62K LUT at 3.91 LUT per SLICE.
- **MLPV (Q5120 base)** = 0x1349 per SLR minus its own 256 lanes. The lanes are placed by URAM as 102 / 53 / 101, at 5 URAM per lane.
- **MLPV (record base)** = M1361 per SLR minus its E3 array of 142 / 35 / 79 lanes at 2 URAM per lane.
- The record ATT base goes negative in SLR2: its lane is about 243 SLICE, not 277. So the ATT is priced on the Q5120 base only.
- Script: `survey_evidence/a16_fit.py` (md5 `924d1163a76392c1a31cc300911a1f4b`); output `survey_evidence/a16_fit.out` (md5 `5a69a9fd68bef8eff858a97623261d96`).

### 1.3 Headroom table at A16: v0 geometry (ATT LANES 512, MLPV LANES 256), per card and per SLR
Each SLR is listed as SLR0 / SLR1 / SLR2. Lane counts are at 100 % of each die, with the 90 %-SLICE practical bar in brackets. The binding resource for each row is given in words.

**Free after the base**

| card (base) | SLICE free | DSP free | URAM free |
|---|---|---|---|
| ATT (0x1346 + G7 delta) | 85.2K / 6.8K / 106.7K | 3,965 / 979 / 3,408 | 677 / 479 / 624 |
| MLPV (0x1349 minus array) | 36.3K / 21.5K / 30.9K | 3,966 / 1,161 / 3,354 | 677 / 624 / 624 |
| MLPV (0x1361 minus array) | 50.3K / 13.9K / 22.1K | 3,933 / 1,237 / 3,294 | 677 / 624 / 624 |

**ATT card, v0 needs 512 lanes**

| lane form | max lanes per SLR | total [90 %] | binding | v0 fits? | products per cycle at max |
|---|---|---|---|---|---:|
| LUT A8 K32 (shipped, reference) | 307 / 24 / 312 | 643 [579] | SLICE in SLR0/SLR1, URAM in SLR2 | yes | 20,576 |
| **LUT A16 K32 x1.49** | 206 / 16 / 258 | **480 [411]** | SLICE | **no** | 15,360 |
| LUT A16 K32 x2.1 | 146 / 11 / 183 | 340 [292] | SLICE | no | 10,880 |
| LUT A16 K64 x1.49 | 149 / 12 / 187 | 348 [298] | SLICE | no | **22,272** |
| LUT A16 K128 x1.49 | 96 / 7 / 121 | 224 [191] | SLICE | no | **28,672** |
| **DSP E3 A16 K32** | 198 / 33 / 170 | **401 [368]** | DSP in SLR0/SLR2, SLICE in SLR1 | **no** | 12,832 |
| DSP E3 A16 K64 | 110 / 26 / 94 | 230 [204] | DSP | no | 14,720 |
| **HYBRID A16 K32 (x1.49)** | (127 LUT + 159 E3) / (0 + 33) / (205 + 107) | **631** | SLICE + DSP together | **yes** | 20,192 |
| HYBRID A16 K32 (x2.1) | (85 + 172) / (0 + 33) / (138 + 128) | 556 | SLICE + DSP together | yes | 17,792 |

**MLPV card, v0 needs 256 lanes**

| lane form | max lanes per SLR | total [90 %] | binding | v0 fits? | products per cycle at max |
|---|---|---|---|---|---:|
| LUT A8 K32 (shipped, reference) | 131 / 77 / 111 | 319 [203] | SLICE | at 100 % only | 10,208 |
| **LUT A16 K32 x1.49** | 88 / 52 / 75 | **215 [136]** | SLICE | **no** | 6,880 |
| LUT A16 K32 x2.1 | 62 / 36 / 53 | 151 [96] | SLICE | no | 4,832 |
| LUT A16 K128 x1.49 | 41 / 24 / 35 | 100 [62] | SLICE | no | 12,800 |
| **DSP E3 A16 K32** | 175 / 58 / 149 | **382 [273]** | SLICE in SLR0/SLR2, DSP in SLR1 | **yes** | 12,224 |
| DSP E3 A16 K64 | 110 / 32 / 93 | 235 [207] | DSP | no (at 256 lanes) | **15,040** |
| HYBRID A16 K32 (x1.49) | (0 + 175) / (28 + 48) / (0 + 149) | 400 | SLICE + DSP together | yes | 12,800 |
| record base, DSP E3 A16 K32 | 196 / 61 / 107 | 364 [261] | DSP in SLR0/SLR1, SLICE in SLR2 | yes | 11,648 |

What the table says:
- **v0 products per cycle at K32:** ATT 16,384; MLPV 8,192.
- **MLPV, the A16 answer is the record's DSP58 lane, not the LUT lane.** It fits with 126 lanes to spare; at K64 it is DSP-bound at 235 lanes.
- **E3 K64 x L256 would need 9,216 DSP58 against 8,481 free (Q5120 base).** The GLM change measured in `reports/results/DRAFTER_SPEED_RESEARCH_20261107/MLPV_G9_KPAR32_20261112.md` (64 lanes on the fast clock, -1,024 DSP58) makes 9,505 free, so it fits device-wide. Per die it is still short: SLR1 has 1,161 free, about 32 lanes.
- **ATT, both pure forms fall short of 512 at A16.** The options are:
  - a hybrid array (E3 lanes on the DSP-rich SLR0/SLR2, LUT lanes in the remaining SLICE);
  - fewer, wider lanes: about 350 LUT lanes at K64 = 1.36x the v0 products, or 224 at K128 = 1.75x.
- **Every ATT row leaves SLR1 out.** Attention and control hold SLR1 at 93 %, so its 979 DSP and 6.8K SLICE buy almost nothing.

### 1.4 URAM and K (the read-width fact) [D on R + M]
- **What a URAM delivers:** URAM288 is 4,096 rows x 72 b, 2 ports, so 144 b per cycle. The bank stores DATA_W 32 words (`verilog/clean7c/rtl/common/weight_bank_uram.sv:30-31`, md5 `059f61de`). The synthesis packs two 32-bit words per 72-bit row: DEPTH 8,192 x 32 b = 1 URAM per lane, measured 512 for 512 lanes on 0x13BE.
- **What the shipped lane uses:** 2 ports x 16 codes = 32 codes per lane-cycle = 64 of 144 b. A 72-bit port can carry 36 codes at most.
- **K64 (K_PAR 32):** reads the whole 64-bit pair per port, 128 of 144 b. Same URAM count, because a 64-bit entry at half the depth holds the same bits (`BANK64_ENTRY_OOC_20260824.md`, quoted in the Fable doc §1.4). The 128-code group is not a multiple of 36, so 64 is the practical width per port.
- **K128 (K_PAR 64):** needs 256 b per cycle, which is 2 URAMs read side by side. Both v0 cards carry 2 per lane: ATT L512 has 11,680 of 16,384 entries used; MLPV L256 has 14,120 of 16,384.
- **URAM per card does not move with K. It moves with the weight bits / lanes:**
  - ATT TP4 v0 = (4,608·10,240 + 5,120·1,280 + 2·4,096·5,120) / 16 = 5,980,160 32-bit entries. That is a minimum of 730 URAM; 1,024 at L512 (2 per lane); 768 at L384 or L768.
  - MLPV v0 = (5,120·8,192 + 124,160·128) / 16 = 3,614,720 entries. That is a minimum of 442; 512 at L256.

### 1.5 Precision ledger bytes [D on R]
Weight bytes = N·K / 4 for 2-bit codes, N·K / 64 for int16 scales per 128-group, N·K / 512 for 2-bit zeros. Stage shapes come from `ARRAY.md` §4 (record) and `QWEN5120_P1_20261108.md` §1.2 (Q5120).

| card | codes (URAM) | scales int16 (BRAM) | zeros 2-bit (BRAM18) |
|---|---|---|---|
| record ATT 0x13BE (G4 3,072x6,144 + G6 3,072x768 + G7g/u 2,048x3,072) | 8.45 MB (= 4,128 words x 512 lanes x 4 B, ARRAY.md:117) | 0.53 MB | 66 KB |
| record MLPV 0x1361 (G9 6,144x4,096 + G12 64,128x256) | 10.4 MB (10,160 words x 256 x 4 B) | 0.65 MB | none (zero broadcast per group) |
| Q5120 ATT 0x1346 (G4 3,840x10,240 + G6 5,120x1,280) | 11.5 MB (11,200 entries per lane x 256) | 0.72 MB | 90 KB |
| Q5120 MLPV 0x1349 (G7g + G7u 8,192x5,120 + G9 5,120x8,192 + G12 124,160x128) | 35.4 MB | 2.2 MB | 0.28 MB |
| v0 ATT (TP4 v1 split) | 23.9 MB | 1.5 MB | 0.19 MB |
| v0 MLPV | 14.5 MB | 0.90 MB | 0.11 MB |

### 1.6 Hypotheses
- H1: the A16 LUT lane prices at 1.49x the A8 lane in the image, as it does in the lane harness. Not measured in an image; the 2.1x column is the bound if it does not.
- H2: a mixed LUT/E3 array per die can share one stage walk. The two lane forms have different latencies; the E3 lane is a pair unit. No RTL exists for a mixed array; this is an RTL question for the RTL agent.
- H3: SLICE % is partly a placer outcome (0x1349 94.45 % vs 0x135E 78.81 % on near-identical netlists), so the 100 % column is reachable only with the AggressiveExplore-class recipe; the 90 % column is the safer plan.
- H4: A16 doubles the activation broadcast into each die. About +256 nets per cut at K32 (feed 493 nets per cut at A8, `LUTGEMM_LANE_E3_20261102.md`). This is not binding on either card's SLL (§2), but it is the known H5120 timing wall, so it needs the ACT_XPIPE form.

---

## 2. Device and per-SLR utilisation per image (measured, placed / routed)
Each per-SLR column reads SLR0 / SLR1 / SLR2. SLL figures are used / 18,870 per cut. The V80 totals are LUT 2,574,208, FF 5,148,416, DSP58 10,848, BRAM36 tiles 3,741, URAM 1,925, SLICE 321,776.

| image (role, build host, report, md5) | SLICE | LUT | FF | DSP58 | BRAM tiles | URAM | SLL 1<->0 / 2<->1 | binding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **0x13BE** record ATT HCUT, Llama H3072, L512 LUTG A8; buildx04 `s3LAtp4BE` placed, `BE_place_report_utilization_0.rpt` `03fdd895` | 263,389 (81.85 %); 110,410 / 70,094 / 82,885 = 98.12 / 68.37 / 77.67 % | 1,023,252 (39.75 %); 45.69 / 31.00 / 41.90 % | 932,324 (18.11 %) | 5,267 (48.55 %); 3,546 / 694 / 1,027 = 89.0 / 20.1 / 30.1 % | 1,783 (47.66 %) | 744 (38.65 %); 232 / 171 / 341 | 9,501 (50.4 %) / 1,880 (10.0 %) | **SLICE in SLR0** |
| **0x1361** record MLPV G8_OWN, L256 E3 A16 (M1361 routed `-slr`, `M1361_final_slr_util.rpt` `edfa7302`; device totals from build placed `M61build_…` `bf16ecff`) | 288,227 per-SLR sum (89.6 %); 91,520 / 95,807 / 100,900 = 81.33 / 93.44 / 94.55 % | 1,185,094; 35.70 / 50.31 / 52.83 % | 1,018,982 (19.8 %) | 7,504 (69.17 %); 2,891 / 2,919 / 1,694 = 72.6 / 84.5 / 49.7 % | 1,035.5 (27.7 %) | 512 (26.6 %); 284 / 70 / 158 | 14,764 (78.2 %) / 12,533 (66.4 %) | **SLICE in SLR2/SLR1**, then SLR1 DSP, then SLL 1<->0 |
| **0x1346** Q5120 ATT TP4, L256 LUTG A8, 10x128 heads HP5/HPS2; buildx04 `~/build4c1/s3LAq5120t4c` placed, `Q46_place_…` `0670e6d2`; route WNS -2.565 (failed setup: area only) | 177,862 (55.28 %); 11,306 / 95,700 / 70,856 = 10.05 / 93.34 / 66.39 % | 661,503 (25.70 %); 3.79 / 42.73 / 32.44 % | 693,438 (13.47 %) | 4,036 (37.21 %); 19 / 2,477 / 1,540 | 1,367.5 (36.55 %); 24 / 959.5 / 384 | 657 (34.13 %); 0 / 145 / 512 | 3,328 (17.6 %) / 2,233 (11.8 %) | **SLICE in SLR1** (SLR0 empty) |
| **0x134A** = 0x1346 + G6_EARLY_ISSUE + KVF_TFIX, stopped copy on buildx00 `~/build4c1/s3LAq5120t4k` placed, `Q4A_place_…` `e40e6d2e` (closed copy +0.047/+0.011 is on buildxd05, not opened) | 177,186 (55.07 %); 9.81 / 93.06 / 66.28 % | 658,621 (25.59 %) | 693,717 (13.47 %) | 4,036 (37.21 %) | 1,367.5 | 657; 0 / 145 / 512 | 3,243 / 2,277 | **SLICE in SLR1** |
| **0x1349** Q5120 MLPV L256 LUTG A8, TREE_P 32, G8_W2; buildx00 `s3LCq5120m49` placed, `Q49_place_…` `5a21d27e` | 303,917 (94.45 %); 104,451 / 95,738 / 103,728 = 92.82 / 93.38 / 97.20 % | 1,376,072 (53.46 %); 46.65 / 59.00 / 55.31 % | 1,285,443 (24.97 %) | 4,256 (39.23 %); 771 / 2,686 / 799 | 2,271.5 (60.72 %); 708 / 953.5 / 610 | 1,280 (66.49 %); 510 / 265 / 505 | 12,413 (65.8 %) / 12,420 (65.8 %) | **SLICE, every SLR** |
| **0x135E** Q5120 MLPV (+A8Q_INREG; place AggressiveExplore); buildy03 `s3LCq5120m5E` placed, `Q5E_place_…` `2f61df52`; route +0.013 (`CONFIG_MANIFEST_135E.md`) | 253,589 (78.81 %); 72.37 / 90.78 / 74.10 % | 1,367,658 (53.13 %) | 1,286,295 (24.98 %) | 4,256 (39.23 %); 738 / 2,875 / 643 | 2,271.5 | 1,280; 500 / 350 / 430 | 12,559 (66.6 %) / 11,011 (58.4 %) | **SLICE in SLR1** |
| **0x135D** Q5120 MLPV L256/TP64/THARD + A8Q_INREG; buildxd05 (not opened: box1-two-v2 partition) | 96.30 % / worst SLR 99.58 % | 64.39 % | | 39.23 % | 60.72 % | 66.49 % | 13,269 / 12,011 | SLICE; route -2.862 |

The 0x135D row is the census line `SYNTH_CENSUS_WEEK_20261105_12.md:269`.

## 3. Per-instance hierarchy (measured, drafter IP OOC synth dcp, `report_utilization -hierarchical`, pre-opt)

Each row reads LUT / FF / RAMB36 / RAMB18 / URAM / DSP. The line number is that of the instance row in the image's `*_synth_hier.rpt`, and the md5 of each report is in the source line at the end of this section. Each dcp was copied from `.../prj.runs/top_eagle4_drafter_lb_0_0_synth_1/`; the copy md5s are in `survey_evidence/*_ooc_dcp.md5.txt`.

| block | record ATT 0x13BE | Q5120 ATT 0x1346 | record MLPV 0x1361 | Q5120 MLPV 0x1349 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| drafter total | 1,046,766 / 940,325 / 1,362 / 610 / 744 / 5,459 (:25) | 645,796 / 653,474 / 1,091 / 321 / 657 / 4,100 (:25) | 1,574,493 / 935,306 / 931 / 26 / 512 / 7,602 (:25) | 1,465,370 / 1,230,084 / 2,187 / 26 / 1,280 / 4,419 (:25) |
| **GEMV array u_array** | **597,623** / 466,864 / 512 / 512 / 512 / 1,635 (:32) | **311,016** / 241,632 / 256 / 256 / 512 / 1,633 (:30) | **147,305** / 137,895 / 280 / 0 / 512 / **5,120** (:31) | **311,050** / 236,414 / 1,536 / 0 / 1,280 / 1,889 (:30) |
| array lanes | 512 x `lutgemm_lane_w2` 988 / 628 / DSP 1 (:39) | 256 x 986 / 627 / DSP 1 (:37) | 256 x E3 lane 348 / 366 / DSP 1 (:37) + 256 x pair dot 125 / 53 / DSP 17 (:33,:35) | 256 x 988 / 628 / DSP 1 (:37); u_bank 54 LUT / 5 URAM / 2 DSP per lane (:41) |
| A8 quantizer `u_a8q` | 5,356 / 707 / DSP 96 (:34) | 5,282 / 715 / DSP 96 (:32) | none (A16) | 5,260 / 704 / DSP 96 (:32) |
| attention `u_attn_full` | 164,151 / 169,464 / 672 / 64 / 232 / 3,416 (:2181); 8 engines x 10,974 LUT / 395 DSP | 127,275 / 123,022 / 673 / 47 / 145 / 2,221 (:1092); 5 engines x 11,470 / 393 DSP | none | none |
| KV `u_kv` (K URAM, V BRAM, 16-bit) | 10,392 LUT / 448 RAMB36 / 64 RAMB18 / 232 URAM (:2319) | 6,326 / 560 / 40 / 145 URAM (:1179) | none | none |
| RoPE `u_rope` | 5,818 / 216 RAMB36 / 256 DSP (:2321) | 2,177 / 108 RAMB36 / 256 DSP (:1181) | none | none |
| G6 TP exchange `u_tp` (48-b partials) | 104,881 / 45,059 / 11 RAMB36 / 32 DSP, LUTRAM 14,056 (:29) | 50,679 / 21,879 / 11, LUTRAM 7,036 (:29) | none | none |
| G8 exact rescore `u_g8` | none | none | 314,123 / 71,687 / DSP 84 (:821); 4 fp16 dots x 22,751 LUT / 16 DSP (:825) | 358,081 / 77,246 / DSP 100, LUTRAM 10,688 (:1337); 4 W2 dots x 23,634 LUT / 4 DSP (:1341), plus 4 legacy fp16 dots x 23,429 / 16 DSP still present pre-opt (:1342) |
| GLM `g_glm.u_lmdown` (bf16 down-proj x 16-bit act) | none | none | 30,240 / 79,439 / DSP 2,048 (:29) | 30,543 / 79,436 / DSP 2,048 (:29) |
| TREE `u_tree` / `u_cheap_ser` / `u_tree_tiler` | none | none | 75,099 / 46,280 (LUTRAM 15,360) / 13,743 (:854,:852,:853) | 75,099 / 46,292 / 13,800 (:1427,:1425,:1426) |
| tree DMA / out-walk / bridge | none | none | 45,675 / 13,523 / 21,445 (:808,:810,:807) | same values (:1324,:1326,:1323) |
| fp16/int16 activation seams (FF) | r4g / r4u 3,697 / 3,868 (SDP BRAM 4 each); g5g6 657 / 8 RAMB36 | r1_e 796 / 8 RAMB36; g5g6 7,439 / 8 RAMB36 | r1_e / r1_h 17,460 / 17,769, 50,182 FF each; r5 23,075 / 66,824; r8 17,308 / 49,427; r6 16,397 / 49,161 | r1_e / r1_h 56,615 / 56,320, 83,512 FF each; **r5 89,822 / 133,436**; r8 28,700 / 82,197; r6 27,406 / 81,930 |
| RMSNorm (each of g1, g1_e, premlp, g11, g1_e_d) | ~2,100-2,450 / ~975 / DSP 48 | ~2,060-2,340 / ~980 / DSP 48 | ~2,050-2,250 / ~970 / DSP 48 | ~2,040-2,360 / ~975 / DSP 48 |
| SiLU `u_silu` | 3,010 / 545 / DSP 32 | none (G7 not on this ATT) | none | 3,010 / 545 / DSP 32 |
| `u_ctrl` | 28,926 | n/a (< 10K row) | 48,100 | 50,840 |
| drafter own logic `(inst)` | 68,776 / 202,087 | 102,170 / 227,659 | 618,175 / 163,190 | 126,842 / 171,957 |

Sources:
- `survey_evidence/BE_synth_hier.rpt` (`2d30e2dea45b19a6e4ac9813a14bda20`)
- `Q46_synth_hier.rpt` (`40a9594fb6d41191ffcc1c11f3e2399d`)
- `M61_synth_hier.rpt` (`bd5ad4a233569d4c3274dc5c1659f7e3`)
- `Q49_synth_hier.rpt` (`263db434979bd53207b962fca90b6984`)
- `Q5E_synth_hier.rpt` (`30c9b4a8f3d9fe7daf65cc53c5896388`), which matches 0x1349 within 0.3 % per block
- Depth-2 digest of all five: `hier_depth2_summary.txt`

Notes:
- **The array memories are not attributed to any child row.** Inside u_array, the bank / scale / zero memories (URAM, RAMB36, RAMB18) and some DSP and LUT (0x1346: 23,808 LUT, 768 DSP) show in the u_array total but in no child row, except 0x1349's `u_bank`. Per-lane memory counts above are the u_array totals divided by the lanes.
- **Synth vs placed:** synth totals are above the placed totals (e.g. 0x1349 1,465,370 synth vs 1,376,072 placed, which also includes the shell). opt_design prunes logic such as the legacy fp16 dots.

## 4. Precision ledger (measured placement of each precision class; bytes in §1.5)

### 4.1 Storage
| precision class | record ATT 0x13BE | record MLPV 0x1361 | Q5120 ATT 0x1346 | Q5120 MLPV 0x1349 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2-bit weight codes, 16 per 32-b word | URAM 512, 1 per lane, DEPTH 8,192 (ARRAY.md:117; u_array :32) | URAM 512, 2 per lane, DEPTH 16,384 (:117; u_array :31) | URAM 512, 2 per lane (u_array :30; all in SLR2, placed `:411`) | URAM 1,280, 5 per lane (u_bank :41) |
| GPTQ scales (Q3.13, int16; Qwen F 16, `GEMV_SCALE_FRAC 16`) | RAMB36 512, 1 per lane (`GEMV_SCALE_FRAC 13`, `verilog/clean7c/ref/att_13be/CONFIG_MANIFEST.md:111`) | RAMB36 256 (+ 24 LCACHE activation BRAM = 280) | RAMB36 256 | RAMB36 1,536 (6 per lane: scale + zero banks for 5 URAM of weights) |
| GPTQ-v2 2-bit zero | RAMB18 512, per (lane, group) | **none: one zero per group, broadcast** (`qz_raw`, ARRAY.md:119) | RAMB18 256 | within the 1,536 RAMB36 |
| activations inside the GEMV | int8 (A8Q), FF per 8-lane cluster | **int16 (A16)**, BRAM per-die cache, then FF | int8 (A8Q) | int8 (A8Q) |
| fp16/int16 activation seams | SDP BRAM (SEAM_BRAM_W 1) and FF: small (§3 seam row) | FF: r1 / r5 / r6 / r8 ~92K LUT, ~266K FF | SDP BRAM, small | FF: ~259K LUT, ~465K FF |
| KV cache fp16 | K URAM 232 (8 heads x 96), V 448 RAMB36 + 64 RAMB18 (u_kv :2319) | none | K URAM 145 (10 heads x 128, HPS 2), V 560 RAMB36 + 40 RAMB18 (:1179) | none |
| RoPE tables | 216 RAMB36 | none | 108 RAMB36 | none |
| norm gamma | inside rmsnorm / drafter own logic: no separate RAM row | same | same | same |
| cheap lm-head (G12) 2-bit | none | in the array URAM (4,016 words per lane of 10,160) | none | in the array URAM |
| exact lm-head rows (G8) | none | **fp16 in HBM**: 128,256 x 3,072 x 2 B = 788 MB (`DESIGN_DUAL_MODEL_4C1.md:144`) | none | **2-bit in HBM**: codes 317.8 + scales 19.9 + zeros 2.5 = 340.2 MB, 1,408 B per row vs 6,144 B fp16 at H3072 / 10,240 B at H5120 (`DESIGN_FABLE_FULL2BIT_LUT_ARRAY_20261102.md:89`; `P2_G8W2_20261108.md:7`) |
| G8 hidden-state store | (FF row buffers in u_g8 own logic) | | | LUTRAM 10,688 in the W2 dots (:1341) |

### 4.2 Compute
| precision class | record ATT 0x13BE | record MLPV 0x1361 | Q5120 ATT 0x1346 | Q5120 MLPV 0x1349 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2-bit x activation GEMV | **2b x A8 in LUT**: 512 lanes x 988 LUT; u_array 597,623 LUT / 1,635 DSP | **2b x A16 on DSP58**: 256 lanes x (348 + 125) LUT / 18 DSP plus bank / scale DSP; u_array 147,305 LUT / **5,120 DSP** | 2b x A8 in LUT: 256 x 986; u_array 311,016 / 1,633 DSP | 2b x A8 in LUT: 256 x 988; u_array 311,050 / 1,889 DSP |
| lane accumulators | 48-b (`result_q`, ARRAY.md:135), inside the lane rows | same | same | same |
| attention QK / softmax / PV (16-bit) | 8 engines, 87,792 LUT / 3,160 DSP | none | 5 engines, 57,350 LUT / 1,965 DSP | none |
| RMSNorm (fp/int 16-b, 48 DSP each) | 4 instances | 4 instances (incl. g11) | 4 | 4 |
| GLM low-rank (bf16 x 16-b) | none | 2,048 DSP | none | 2,048 DSP |
| G8 rescore dot | none | fp16 x fp16 wide dot, 4 x (22,751 LUT, 16 DSP) | none | exact 2-bit x int dot, 4 x (23,634 LUT, 4 DSP); `P2_G8W2_20261108.md:108-113`: u_g8 at H5120 -29,291 LUT, -3,463 FF, -48 DSP vs fp16 |
| TREE top-K (16-bit scores) | none | 75,099 LUT u_tree | none | 75,099 LUT |

## 5. Record -> Q5120 delta per card (measured, same instrument)

### 5.1 ATT (0x13BE -> 0x1346; different lane counts by design: L512 1 URAM per lane vs L256 2 URAM per lane; 0x1346 has no G7)
- **Device (placed):** SLICE 81.85 -> 55.28 %, LUT 39.75 -> 25.70 %, DSP 48.55 -> 37.21 %, URAM 744 -> 657, BRAM 1,783 -> 1,367.5.
- **Array:** 597,623 -> 311,016 LUT, which is the lane count (512 -> 256). The lane itself is unchanged at 988 / 986 LUT.
- **Attention:** 8 heads x 96 -> 10 heads x 128 per card, with 8 -> 5 engines. LUT 164K -> 127K, DSP 3,416 -> 2,221, K URAM 232 -> 145, V RAMB36 448 -> 560.
- **G6 exchange u_tp:** 104,881 -> 50,679 LUT, which is the lane count again.
- **SLR placement:** the 0x1346 array sits wholly in SLR2 (URAM 512 = 82 %), and attention plus control sit in SLR1 (93.3 % SLICE). SLR0 is nearly empty.

### 5.2 MLPV (0x1361 -> 0x1349)

**What grew:**
- **URAM 512 -> 1,280,** because G7g/G7u moved onto the MLPV in the Q5120 v0 split.
- **BRAM 1,035.5 -> 2,271.5 tiles,** from the scale banks for those weights.
- **GEMV array LUT 147K -> 311K** (A16 DSP -> A8 LUT form).
- **G8 u_g8 314K -> 358K LUT pre-opt.**
- **Seams r1 / r5 / r6 / r8 about 92K -> 259K LUT and about 266K -> 465K FF:** H 5120 and the G7 hand-off.
- **Vocab:** TREE_V_MAX 128,256 -> 248,320 (CONFIG_MANIFEST_1349.md:185). The u_tree / u_cheap_ser rows are identical (75,099 / 46,292), so the vocabulary grew in the G12 bank and the tiling, not in the merge.

**What shrank:**
- **DSP 7,504 -> 4,256:** array 5,120 -> 1,889.
- **Drafter own logic 618K -> 127K LUT.**
- **The 2-bit G8 dot:** -29,291 LUT / -3,463 FF / -48 DSP at H5120 against fp16 (`P2_G8W2_20261108.md:108-113`).
- **The HBM head:** 788 MB fp16 -> 340 MB 2-bit.

**Net:** device SLICE 89.6 -> 94.45 %, LUT 46 -> 53 %, DSP 69 -> 39 %.

## 6. Run log and instrument record
- **Routed / postroute dcp surveys:** `survey_util.tcl` (`76676fd0`) via `run_survey.sh` (`999ba2ae`) were run on buildx04 (0x13BE, 0x1346, 0x1349 copy md5 `071dd632` = the adjudicated final dcp), buildxd00 (M1361_final.dcp) and buildy00 (0x135E copy md5 `cdcf1631` = source).
  - All runs stopped at open_checkpoint: `ERROR: [Netlist 29-57] IP License required ... top_i/base_logic/axi_smbus_rpu/inst`, `FlexNet Licensing error:-95,378. System Error: 104 "Connection reset by peer"` (`Q46_run.out:26-34`, `BE_run.out:26-34`). That is with `ss` showing 127.0.0.1:2101 listening and `authorized_keys` carrying the tunnel line on every VM tried.
  - **The tunnel port is up and the server behind it is not.** This is the same state as the 11-16 post-reboot census commit `49d64afde`, "licence 2101 dead on all VMs".
- **Synth hierarchies:** `synth_hier.tcl` (`dd975bbf`) via `run_synth_hier.sh` (`bb3eb805`), on buildx04 `/shared/scratch/qsurvey_20261116/sh/<img>/`, all exit 0.
- **Not opened:** buildxd05 (0x134A closed copy, 0x135D), which is box1-two-v2's partition.
- **Evidence:** `reports/results/QWEN_GPTQ2_20261116/survey_evidence/` (MD5SUMS.txt); parsers `parse_util.py`, `parse_hier.py`.
