# Q&A — decisions waiting on Carrick · 2026-11-05 20:40 EST

**Purpose: this file holds the decisions that will eventually be needed — but they are deferred.** Before ruling on
any of them the session must be able to state the architecture and the development cycle correctly, which is what
`~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is for. Answer that
brief first; then these six become answerable in one pass. Editing a `DECISION:` line is still how a ruling is made.

## Cold-start: the state in ten lines

| # | fact | evidence |
|---:|---|---|
| 1 | The programme runs a 2-bit EAGLE-4 drafter on Alveo V80s; an H200 verifies the tree. Target: beat H200-only inference on the same host. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/OPERATOR_CONTEXT_20261105.md` §1 |
| 2 | 4C1 record parity is real: Llama **728.96 / 731.40 / 730.02 tok/s @ accept 5.88**, Qwen 236–240 @ 7.14. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/SEVENCARD_BOARD_20261026/SIBW_BUILD_WATCH_20261026.md` tail |
| 3 | **The array loses end to end at bs 1**: GPU-only 826.58 vs FPGA 723.09, and 1.280 vs 1.409 J/token. It wins only on **drafter forward, 0.177 vs 0.37 ms (2.1×)**. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/TALON2_POWER_ECON_20261104.md`, `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/FOURCARD_DESIGN_20261016/GPU_VS_FPGA_DRAFTER_20261019.md` |
| 4 | Correctness is closed. The 0x133C G5 hang was an MBUFGCE leaf-divider startup skew; two clock-only fixes exist — **fix C** (`0x133F`) and **fix B** (`0x1340`). Keep B: C closes hold only on placement luck. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/SEVENCARD_BOARD_20261026/RCA_0x133C_G5_HANG_20261103.md` |
| 5 | L512 was never a silicon wall — it was a floorplan (hub in SLR1, consumers in SLR0). **E2b `0xE4B713E2` closes at `+0.043/+0.012`**, PDI `2540c725…`, quarantined. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/QWEN27B_DRAFTER_20261020/LUTGEMM_ATT_INTEGRATION_D9_20261102.md` §7d |
| 6 | Blocker is visibility, not engineering: asgard's LAN has been down since 11-05 07:47Z, so E0's own AMC firmware and its gate rows cannot be read. | Q1 below |
| 7 | Open build: `0xE4B713EB` (same netlist, E0 floorplan, no BalancedSLR) placed at `+0.124 / −0.436`, routing on buildx03. | Q1, Q3 |
| 8 | Truth hierarchy: HQ → operator pack → evidence set → domain briefs → scripts → site. Read in that order. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/HQ_20261105.md` |
| 9 | **Do not read** `NOW.md` (content ~09-14), `ITINERARY.md` (07-08), `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/PDI_BUILD_INDEX.md` (07-10). They are the inverted truth hierarchy. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/HQ_20261105.md` §5 |
| 10 | Two rules that keep everything else honest: **gates report, never kill**; **identity is the PDI md5, never reg 0x100**. | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/MUST_PASS_VERIFICATION_LIST.md`, `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/scripts/preflash_gate.sh` |

---

Answer format, any of these is fine:

```
DECISION: B — hold until asgard is back
DECISION: A, because the card is cheap to recover
DECISION: 1A 2C 3B 4A 5B          # all at once, by number
```

**Where this file lives (absolute):**

| copy | absolute path |
|---|---|
| **canonical** | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/Q_AND_A_20261105.md` |
| beside the review that prompted it | `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/Q_AND_A_20261105.md` |
| authoring copy | `~/Desktop/research/eagle/Q_AND_A_20261105.md` |

The reply file it sits next to: `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/STATUS_REVIEW_CORRECTED_20261105.md`
(box1 = [private-ip] per `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/build_machine_setup/README.md:593`).

Cross-references: `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/HQ_20261105.md` §7 · `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/OPERATOR_CONTEXT_20261105.md` §11 · evidence in
`~/Desktop/research/eagle/review_20261105/` (local) and `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/reports/results/` (repo).

---

## Q1. May E2b (`0xE4B713E2`) be flashed onto talon2 17/3d?

**What is proven.** First timing-clean L512 LUT-GEMM ATT image: `^FINAL_TRUE WNS=+0.043 WHS=+0.012` (bar
+0.030/+0.010), SLL SLR1↔SLR0 8,986 of 18,870 (47.6 %), PDI `2540c725ff966cfc89571375b98a71c3`, 76,725,008 B,
magic `16a5f792`, same netlist as `0xE4B713E0` (reg100 `0xE4B711E0`). Preflash receipt: **`n_img_fail=0`,
`n_img_unver=4`, `rc=3 BLOCKED_IMAGE_UNVERIFIED`** — nothing failed, four things could not be read.

**What is not proven.**

| # | unverified | why it is stuck | what closes it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | the AMC firmware in the FPT is **`0x13DE`'s** (`amc.elf cd6cc996`, `fpt.bin 45f47718`), not E0's own | asgard unreachable since 11-05 07:47Z | asgard back, or a rebuild with E0's FW |
| 2 | E0's in-pipeline gate rows (`GATE_VERDICTS_*` on asgard) unread | same | same |
| 3 | **no full-drafter replay at LANES 512**, and `RET_SER=1` has never been in one | L512 replay lives on darehard, unreadable | darehard/laptop back, or a talon2 replay after flash |
| 4 | host zero-bank load + G6 per-rank A8 scale ruling (same as `0x13DE`) | needs a decision, not a build | your call, below |

**Why it might be moot within hours.** `0xE4B713EB` on buildx03 is the same netlist with **E0's own floorplan**
and no BalancedSLR; it placed at **WNS +0.124 / WHS −0.436** and is routing now. If it closes, it supersedes E2b
*and* carries a second chance at a clean FW path.

| | option | cost | risk | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | flash E2b on 17/3d at the next cold AC | burns the slot + ~40 min | borrowed FW on a JTAG-recovery-only path if it wedges | |
| B | **hold E2b until asgard returns, then decide E2b vs EB** | ~0 now; you lose nothing that EB is not already testing | nothing new learned about L512 tonight | **◀ my recommendation** |
| C | rebuild E2b when asgard is up so it carries E0's own FW | 1 build + the queue behind EB | delays the only L512 image that closes | |
| D | other | | | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Q2. Who may flash a quarantined-but-passing PDI?

The rules contradict each other, both written by you:

| source | says |
|---|---|
| `run_arm.sh:40` (the runner, 2026-11-02) | "flashable only after FINAL_TRUE ≥ +0.030/+0.010 + preflash_gate + **USER decision**" |
| `CLAUDE.md` (hard rules) | PDI builds and `-p 0` flash are **pre-authorized** once box1 has adjudicated |

Every fan-out arm lands in that gap. Pick the rule that should win:

| | option | effect | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | ALWAYS explicit — every flash asks you | safest, slowest; you become the queue | |
| B | **pre-authorized iff receipt `rc=0 PASS` AND no `.QUARANTINED` marker** | keeps both rules: the gate decides, you only see exceptions | **◀ my recommendation** |
| C | pre-authorized whenever `n_img_fail=0`, even if `rc=3` | fastest; would have flashed E2b tonight with 4 unknowns | |
| D | per-arm, declared in the slot's `arm.env` | flexible, but the rule moves per build | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Q3. One cold-AC slot, two candidates: which goes first?

| candidate | what it buys | what it costs if it fails |
|---|---|---|
| **E2b** `0xE4B713E2` | first L512 LUT-GEMM ATT on silicon at all | the slot, plus a possible JTAG recovery |
| **`0x1342`** `3e82ea1d` (staged since 11-04) | the clock-arm image already adjudicated and waiting | the slot, and E2b slips another day/AC |

| | option | |
|---|---|---|
| A | **E2b first, only after asgard returns and EB has a verdict** | **◀ my recommendation** — one slot, and EB may hand you a better E2b |
| B | 0x1342 first (it has waited longest, it is fully adjudicated) | |
| C | both in one session if the first boots clean | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Q4. Which verilog branch is canonical?

| fact | value |
|---|---|
| `.gitmodules` points at | `tree-fsm-stage1` |
| the checkout that built every shipped image | `shapert-4c1-20261021` |
| uncommitted at last count | 123 dirty files |
| unapplied stash | 2026-08-26, 54 files |

| | option | |
|---|---|---|
| A | **declare `shapert-4c1-20261021` canonical, freeze it as the shipping branch, mark the submodule pointer historical** | **◀ my recommendation** — it is what the silicon actually came from |
| B | rebase `tree-fsm-stage1` onto it | |
| C | leave it, keep building from whatever is checked out | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Q5. Publish the eleven-day hole on the research site?

The site has 141 posts and 54 diagrams, and **stops at 11-04**. Everything from 10-26 (7-card board) through
tonight (RCA, fix B/C, L512 floorplan, E2b) exists only as repo markdown.

| | option | effort | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | **5 short posts, one per report** (RCA · fix B/C · L512 wall+fix · shadow/JIT diagnosis · E2b closure) | one `push_page.py` run each, ~40 min total | **◀ my recommendation** |
| B | one long "10-26 → 11-05" campaign post | ~20 min, less navigable | |
| C | regenerate the arch-book diagrams too | needs the diagram generator, not in this repo | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Q6. Is the Nov-4 rank-128 head idea a directive or a hypothesis?

`CONCLUSIONS_20261104.md` / `fpga_lut_engine_20261104.md` (this Mac) argue the drafter is ~18 % of round cost vs
82 % verify, and propose dropping the rank-128 head to save 3.3× bytes. That is an argument with numbers, not a
measurement, and it changes the datapath.

| | option | |
|---|---|---|
| A | **hypothesis — gate it behind a measurement before any RTL** | **◀ my recommendation** |
| B | directive — start the design now | |
| C | park it until the 7-card programme has a number | |

`DECISION:` **deferred** — not mine to rule on until §0 of `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/LEARNING_BRIEF_20261105.md` is corrected by the trantor agent.


---

## Answered log

| date (UTC) | # | state | unblocks when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-06 | Q1–Q6 | **deferred** | the learning brief §0 is corrected, so the trade-offs are stated in the machine's real terms |

*The provisional calls written earlier (hold E2b, rc=0 pre-authorization, B before C, branch canonicalisation, five
posts, rank-128 as hypothesis) are withdrawn from this file: they were made before the architecture and dev cycle
could be stated cleanly. They stay in the git history at `a509515f` if the reasoning is wanted later.*

*Written 2026-11-05 20:40 EST. Facts trace to `~/workspace/eagle4_adaptation/hardware/cleanup_EAGLE/docs/HQ_20261105.md` §4; the four E2b unknowns are itemised in the
image's own `*.QUARANTINED` marker on box1 and in its `*.PREFLASH_RECEIPT`.*
---

## Q1 update — 2026-11-07 04:35Z (box1-qwen-junior; append-only)

The Q1 hold condition ("hold until asgard returns and EB has a verdict") is now met. Both D9 L512 images compared:

| | E2b 0xE4B713E2 | EB 0xE4B713EB |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | FINAL_TRUE **+0.043 / +0.012** (bar +0.030 / +0.010) | ROUTED **−2.074** / 0.000, after 27.5 h of route; FINAL_TRUE still to come |
| PDI | md5 `2540c725ff966cfc89571375b98a71c3`, 76,725,008 B | none flashable |
| Open unknowns | none: firmware (§9), RET_SER (§10) and L512 full-drafter replay (§11) closed in `reports/results/QWEN27B_DRAFTER_20261020/lutgemm_d9_evidence/ADJUDICATION_0xE4B713E2.md` | — |
| preflash_gate | rc=3: quarantine marker (needs the user), PDI-6 strap evidence and PDI-7 seam check, both also unverified on the silicon-proven 0x13DE | — |

**The decision for the user:** flash E2b to talon2 cards 17/3d (kit staged, run gated on `D9E2_FLASH_GO=<md5>`), or keep holding. EB is diagnostic only.
